Senate Voting Results

Tribunus Plebis Fr. Apulus Caesar Omnibus SPD

The session of the Senate is closed and the votes have been tallied as follows:

Formal debate ended on January 24th at 12:30 PM CET. Voting began immediately afterwards and ended on January 28th at 17:20 PM CET.

The results were officially published by the presiding Consul Gnaeus Salix Astur on the Senate list on January 28th 2757 (01/28/2004).

The following Senators cast votes in time. They are referred to below by a code composed by their initials:

CSA - Cn. Salix Astur
CEM - Cn. Equitius Marinus
MOG - M. Octavius Germanicus
LSD - L. Sicinius Drusus
CON - Cn. Octavius Noricus
KFQ - K. Fabius Quintilianus
AICPM - Alexander I.C. Probus Macedonicus
AGG - A. Gryllus Graecus
MAM - M. Arminius Maior
MMA - M. Minucius Audens
PC - Patricia Cassia
TLF - T. Labienus Fortunatus
QFM - Q. Fabius Maximus
DIS - D. Iunius Silanus
FAC - Fr. Apulus Caesar
AMC - Ap. Marcellus Cato
MCI - M. Cassius Iulianus
LSA - L. Sergius Australicus
LEC - L. Equitius Cincinnatus
CMM - C. Marius Merullus
DIP - D. Iunius Palladius
CFD - C. Flavius Diocletianus
LPO - L. Pompeius Octavianus

Only Senator Lucius Cornelius Sulla failed to vote.

Remember that "VTI ROGAS" indicates a vote in favor of an item, "ANTIQUO" is a vote against, and "ABSTINEO" is an abstention.

The overall results are as follow:

I. Approval of the Lex Labiena de Iure Civium, presented to the Comitia Centuriata a.d. IV Idus Decembris anno MMDCCLVI (December the 8th 2003) by the consul T. Labienus Fortunatus and approved by the Comitia Centuriata a.d. VIII Kal. Ianuariis (December the 25th). [please, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Nova-Roma/message/18009 if you would read the original text]

Item I passes with 22 votes in favor (2/3 of the votes of the Senate), 0 opposing and 1 abstentions.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - VTI ROGAS
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - VTI ROGAS
CON - VTI ROGAS
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - VTI ROGAS
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - VTI ROGAS
DIS - VTI ROGAS
FAC - VTI ROGAS
AMC - VTI ROGAS
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - VTI ROGAS
LEC - VTI ROGAS
CMM - VTI ROGAS
DIP - VTI ROGAS: A long overdue change.
CFD - VTI ROGAS
LPO - ABSTINEO


II. Approval of the Lex Labiena de Gentibus, presented to the Comitia Centuriata a.d. IV Idus Decembris anno MMDCCLVI (December the 8th 2003) by the consul T. Labienus Fortunatus and approved by the Comitia Centuriata a.d. VIII Kal. Ianuariis (December the 25th). [please, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Nova-Roma/message/18009 if you would read the original text]

Item II passes with 18 votes in favor (2/3 of the votes of the Senate), 2 opposing and 3 abstentions.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - VTI ROGAS
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - VTI ROGAS
CON - VTI ROGAS
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - VTI ROGAS
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS: since the Comitia has approved it. However, I have reservations about whether this law is sufficient to ensure the rights and freedoms of Gens members, and urge the Consuls to further refine it at the earliest opportunity.
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - ABSTINEO
DIS - ABSTINEO: I have concerns that this could result in a plethora of one person families with substantially less cohesion and support that the current system affords. However, it is certainly more historical and I am loathe to vote against it.
FAC - VTI ROGAS
AMC - VTI ROGAS: I call on the Consuls to help implement this change by promulgating leges dealing with Naturalization and Adoption.
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - VTI ROGAS
LEC - VTI ROGAS
CMM - ANTIQVO
DIP - ANTIQVO: A change that comes far too soon. It will create hundreds of one person families with no sense of kinship with others in their gentes. It does nothing to unify Nova Roma.
CFD - VTI ROGAS
LPO - ABSTINEO


III. Approval of the Lex Fabia Labiena de Iure Augurum, presented to the Comitia Centuriata a.d. IV Idus Decembris anno MMDCCLVI (December the 8th 2003) by the consul T. Labienus Fortunatus and approved by the Comitia Centuriata a.d. VIII Kal. Ianuariis (December the 25th). [please, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Nova-Roma/message/18009 if you would read the original text]

Item III passes with 22 votes in favor (2/3 of the votes of the Senate), 0 opposing and 1 abstentions.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - VTI ROGAS
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - VTI ROGAS
CON - VTI ROGAS
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - VTI ROGAS
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - VTI ROGAS
DIS - VTI ROGAS
FAC - VTI ROGAS
AMC - VTI ROGAS
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - VTI ROGAS
LEC - VTI ROGAS
CMM - VTI ROGAS
DIP - VTI ROGAS
CFD - VTI ROGAS
LPO - ABSTINEO


IV. Approval of the Lex Labiena de Obnuntiatione, presented to the Comitia Centuriata a.d. IV Idus Decembris anno MMDCCLVI (December the 8th 2003) by the consul T. Labienus Fortunatus and approved by the Comitia Centuriata a.d. VIII Kal. Ianuariis (December the 25th). [please, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Nova-Roma/message/18009 if you would read the original text]

Item IV passes with 22 votes in favor (2/3 of the votes of the Senate), 0 opposing and 1 abstentions.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - VTI ROGAS
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - VTI ROGAS
CON - VTI ROGAS
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - VTI ROGAS
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - VTI ROGAS
DIS - VTI ROGAS
FAC - VTI ROGAS
AMC - VTI ROGAS
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - VTI ROGAS
LEC - VTI ROGAS
CMM - VTI ROGAS
DIP - VTI ROGAS
CFD - VTI ROGAS
LPO - ABSTINEO


V. Approval of the Lex Fabia de Civitate Minorum, presented to the Comitia Centuriata a.d. XII Kal. Decembris anno MMDCCLVI (November the 20th 2003) by the consul Q. Fabius Quintilianus and approved by the Comitia Centuriata a.d. III Non. Decembris (December the 3rd). [please, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Nova-Roma/message/16615 if you would read the original text]

Item V is NOT approved with 13 votes in favor, 8 opposing and 2 abstentions. It required 2/3 of the votes of the Senate.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - VTI ROGAS
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - ANTIQVO: I cast this vote in English because I'm voting on this matter as a member of the Board of Directors of Nova Roma Inc. I Would be remiss in my duties to the corporation if I voted yes on a matter that places Nova Roma Inc. in a situation where it could be violating the laws of the nations we operate in. Procedures need to be put in place to ensure that Nova Roma Inc. will be in compliance with national laws regarding minors before this change becomes effective.
CON - ABSTINEO
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - ANTIQVO
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - ANTIQVO: This lex lacks the prudence we need when it comes to minors. One Senator comment that we should pay a lawyer to look over and comment on our liability is the first thing I have heard that makes any sense when it comes this issue. We cannot guess as we have been doing, it is too dangerous to continue in this vein. I hope this lex is defeated. We are simply putting a band aid over a festering wound, and will have to revisit the issue later.
DIS - VTI ROGAS
FAC - VTI ROGAS
AMC - ANTIQVO: I do not vote in favor at this time, for reasons that have already been mentioned by our noble collegue, Senator Drusus.
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - ANTIQVO: I am not opposed to this lex in principle. I voted for it in Comitia. However the concerns raised by Palladius are valid. On closer examination, although this lex says that we will obtain written permission from parent or guardian before admitting a minor to citizenship, it does not say how the Censors will verify that written permission. Given the political/social climate of the macronation that hosts Nova Roma, I think that should be specified.
LEC - ANTIQVO: SIC, I do not vote in favor at this time, for reasons that have already been mentioned by our noble colleague, Senator Drusus.
CMM - VTI ROGAS
DIP - ANTIQVO: This is an incredibly irresponsible proposal by comparison to the current law it hopes to amend--which is only two years old. Nova Roma does not need minors as citizens whose parents are not citizens also. The risk of bad publicity and potential lawsuits is too great. I wish that the senators who voted yes for this would explain their actions with accompanying comments, not one has put remarks with his vote regarding this item. I understand voting for gens reform, even if I don't approve of it; voting for this makes no sense to me.
CFD - ANTIQVO
LPO - ABSTINEO


VI. Appointment of a new propraetor for the Provincia of America Austrorientalis. The sole candidate is:
Gaius Popilius Laenas

Item VI passes with 21 votes in favor, 1 opposing and 1 abstentions.

C. Popilius Laenas is appointed propraetor of America Austrorientalis.

CSA - VTI ROGAS
CEM - ANTIQVO: As much as I respect Gaius Popilius, and understand that he has learned from his recent experiences, I think we would do better to issue a call for candidates for this office. If after such a call Gaius Popilius emerges as the best qualified candidate I will approve him without hesitation.
MOG - VTI ROGAS
LSD - VTI ROGAS
CON - VTI ROGAS
KFQ - VTI ROGAS
AICPM - VTI ROGAS
AGG - VTI ROGAS
MAM - VTI ROGAS
MMA - VTI ROGAS
PC - VTI ROGAS: I believe that Gaius Popilius has learned from his experience, and I also came to respect him during a previous time when I worked with him closely. I believe he will resume his role as a positive force in Nova Roma.
TLF - VTI ROGAS
QFM - VTI ROGAS: Gaius Popilius was doing a good job when the war called him, and now he can pick up where he left off. The fact no one opposed him, shows his province is in agreement.
DIS - VTI ROGAS: I am most pleased to see Gaius Popilius Laenas return to activity. Nova Roma can only benefit from his experience.
FAC - ABSTINEO: I have read several good things and opinions about Illustrus Gaius Popilius Laenas. However I can't give a positive (or negative) vote for two reasons: firstly I don't know him personally and I don't know well the history of his propraetorship. Secondly I think a public call for candidacies could be better and useful.
AMC - VTI ROGAS
MCI - VTI ROGAS
LSA - VTI ROGAS
LEC - VTI ROGAS: I'm very pleased that this is being done in such a timely fashion, without much recrimination, posturing or personal rancor.
CMM - VTI ROGAS
DIP - VTI ROGAS: Welcome back to the position, Laenas!
CFD - VTI ROGAS
LPO - VTI ROGAS


For further information contact the Tribunes Plebis at tribunes@novaroma.org

Valete,
Franciscus Apulus Caesar
Tribunus Plebis

a.d. IV Kal. Feb. MMDCCLVII

Senatus Consulta | Tabularivm | Main Page | Master Index

spt